Carlisle Winery’s Exceptional Old Vine Zinfandels and Rhone Wines from Sonoma

Mike & Kendall Officer

Kendall & Mike Officer

Mike and Kendall Officer launched their Carlisle Winery and Vineyards in 1998 with the goal of creating small lots of distinctive, world-class wines from some of California’s most special and unique vineyards—the old vine Zinfandel and field blends found throughout California and especially in Sonoma County.  While preparing Report #44: The Wines of Sonoma County, we sat down with Mike at his new winery to taste several of the Sonoma County wines he produces, including 18 from head-trained vines on plots planted between 1881 and 1934.  Total production is about 7 thousand cases.

While not well known outside the world of old vine, Zinfandel fanatics, Carlisle Winery has become one of California’s most accomplished producers of old vine Zinfandel and red Rhone varieties. Mike and Kendall had no vineyards of their own until recently when they purchased the Carlisle Vineyard that was planted in 1927 by Alcide Pelletti. They also just recently moved to a new winery after making wine for 14 years in a custom crush facility. The wines are so highly regarded by the cognoscenti that almost all is sold through Mike’s mailing list.  Mike is co-founder of the Historic Vineyard Society with Morgan Twain-Peterson of Bedrock Winery. The Society documents the many special old vines of Sonoma and elsewhere. Excellent descriptions of all the vineyards where Mike sources fruit can be found on the Carlisle web site.

Montafi Vineyard Old Vine Zin

Montafi Vineyard Old Vine Zin

With the assistance of winemaker and viticulturist Jay Maddox, Mike makes wine from a number of Sonoma’s prized vineyards that are populated by old vines, typically Zinfandel and an assortment of mixed blacks like Petite Sirah, Mourvedre, Carignan, and as many as 30 other varieties, some quite obscure. Originally planted in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, often by Italian immigrants, many of these old vines were ripped out and replaced by more productive varieties planted using modern trellising. Others were the victims of the phylloxera epidemic that hit Sonoma in the 1880s and had to be replanted. However, some of the best old vine vineyards survived [see below]. Originally dry-farmed and planted with very wide 10×10 spacing, some have been interplanted to reduce spacing with the addition of drip irrigation.

Bedrock Vineyard

Bedrock Vineyard

Bedrock Vineyard Bedrock Vineyard is located in the Sonoma Valley banana belt where the temperatures are warm and there’s less fog and wind intrusion. Bedrock is today famous for its 35 acres of 125 year-old vines (mostly Zinfandel but, also, mixed-blacks and 30 other obscure varieties) and the magnificent wines produced from them by Sonoma’s outstanding wineries, including Bedrock Wine Co., Ravenswood, Carlisle, Dashe, and Windgap. However, it’s also famous for the historic personalities tied to it.  Originally part of the Mexican land grant owned by General Vallejo, Comandante of Alta California, it was purchased by General Hooker in 1856 with the financial backing of William Tecumseh Sherman, who later led the infamous March to the Sea during the Civil War. Hooker planted the first vitis vinifera vines at Bedrock.  After phylloxera destroyed the vineyard, George Hearst, father of the publisher William Randolph Hearst, purchased the vineyard and began replanting in 1884. Eventually, the vineyard ended up in the hands of the Domenici family, who farmed it for 100 years before selling it to Joel Peterson in 2005.

Tasting Notes and Ratings

ART Carlisle Derivative copyCarlisle 2012 The Derivative Sonoma ($34) 92  An old vine white wine made of Semillon (56%) from Monte Rosso planted in 1886, Muscadelle (30%) from the Pagani Ranch planted in 1920, and Palomino (16%) from the Saltone Ranch in the Russian River Valley planted in 1895. Rich and full from the Semillon, it reveals notes of almonds and nectarine with minerals and bright acidity from the Muscadelle. Superb balance and freshness on a refined palate. This is one of California’s very few old vine white wines made from resuscitated old vine white varieties.

Carlisle 2012 Mourvedre Bedrock Vineyard Sonoma Valley ($40) 91 Bedrock’s 30 acres of old vines dating back to 1888 include two blocks of Mourvedre, which are fermented whole cluster and matured in 20% new French oak. It reveals blue fruit, garrique, and tobacco leaf in an earthy wine with mineral and saline notes. Purity of flavor and freshness show throughout the wine, finishing on a chalky note. Easily handles its 14.9% alcohol.

Carlisle 2012 Two Acres Red Wine Russian River Valley ($45) 93 This old vine Mourvedre-based (78%) blend also contains Petite Sirah, Syrah, Carignan, Peloursin, and Alicante Bouschet from the Two Acre Vineyard planted in 1910. It’s more feminine than the Bedrock Mourvedre with a spicy perfume of light pine needle and cardamon notes and a fine, rich creamy palate. A very pretty wine with rich earth notes, superb balance, and fine grained tannins.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Dry Creek Valley ($36) 93 A beautiful, refined Zinfandel that reveals the rich, pure red fruit for which Dry Creek is famous. There’s lush red and black cherry and a touch of black raspberry fruit perfectly integrated with nice toasted oak. Sourced from three different old vineyards, including 57% from the Teldeschi Ranch, which was planted in the 1890s. Refined with very good acidity and excellent depth and balance despite the high (15.6%) alcohol.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Bedrock Vineyard Sonoma Valley ($43) 93 Mostly Zinfandel (97%) with the rest mixed blacks. The heat of the valley floor contributes lower acidity and firmer tannins than cooler climes. This gorgeous, silky wine reveals rose petals, black raspberry, and white pepper on a fleshy and beautifully balanced palate.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Carlisle Vineyard Russian River Valley ($46) 95 A blockbuster wine that is also complex and suave. Made of 88% Zinfandel planted in 1927. An amazing 39 different varieties, including several whites, comprise the other 12%, and all are cofermented. The wine is one of the most intricate Zinfandels we’ve encountered with abundant spice, dark red fruit, and forest floor notes on a dense, exceptionally elegant palate that is both bold and lively.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Limerick Lane Vineyard Russian River Valley ($43) 94 Made from old vines (1910) planted in the ferrous soils of Limerick Lane, this is pure, opulent wine. Red pomegranate, red cherry and black raspberry show on the nose and again in the mouth with a velvet smooth texture, finishing fine and persistent. Predominantly Zinfandel with small amounts of Peloursin, Petite Sirah and Trousseau.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Montafi Ranch Russian River Valley ($46) 94  A gorgeous wine that reveals a unique bay leaf note from nearby Eucalyptus trees. In addition, there’s brown spices, dark cherry, and dark berries on a soft and generous palate. Incredible purity and length. Made from 87% Zinfandel, 13% mixed blacks planted in 1926.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Monte Rosso Vineyard Sonoma Valley ($46) 93 The 94% Zinfandel, 6% Grand Noir blend from the old vines (1886) of the Monte Rosso Vineyard is pure and elegant, showing a fine perfume of pure dark red cherry. It’s lush yet clean with a rich mouth feel and polished tannins. Absolutely delicious. Made from fully destemmed grapes.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Papera Ranch Russian River Valley ($46) 94+ Big, bold, meaty and savory, this 96% Zinfandel, 4% Carignan comes from a vineyard planted in 1934. The cool climate site contributes a savory character to this incredibly dense, mouthfilling, fleshy but refined wine. Red fruit notes provide a flamboyant character to the wine.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Saitone Ranch Russian River Valley ($46) 93 This is a big, earthy wine showing blackberry, huckleberry, red currant, and spice. It’s very rich and full, partly due to the very firm hardpan that devigorates the vines and reduces yields. There’s huge extract on the very, very long finish. Made from vines planted in 1895 and aged in 25% new French oak. The Palomino interplanted with the Zinfandel and mixed blacks was picked separately.

Carlisle 2012 Zinfandel Sodini Vineyard Russian River Valley ($43) 92 The Sodini Vineyard is located at the far northern part of the Russian River Valley, so this Zinfandel has a lot of Dry Creek character. It shows aromas of red fruit, herbs, and a hint of pine pitch. The attack is pure and focused with red cherry and red raspberry, good acidity, and fine tannins. Lovely focus and freshness.

Mike Potashnik and Don Winkler

March 2015

This entry was posted in California, Countries and Regions, Red Wine, Uncategorized, White Wine, Wine Type and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Carlisle Winery’s Exceptional Old Vine Zinfandels and Rhone Wines from Sonoma

  1. Mike Beltran says:

    Kudos to Mike and Morgan for finding and protecting true old vine Zinfandel. There needs to be a clarification of what is truly old vine Zin. My personal feeling is over 60 years. Today many wineries sell old vine as anything older than 25 years. Totally different animal in my mind. Excellent article.

Comments are closed.